Skip to content
GetProfitable
Search

Failed breakdown and reclaim

Lesson 15 · about 10 min

Every level that the crowd watches is a place where stops sit. When price breaks below a well-known support or a major moving average, those stops fire, shorts pile in, and for a day or two the stock looks broken. If buyers then absorb all of that selling and push price back above the level, everybody who sold or shorted the break is now wrong and has to buy back. That forced buying is the fuel for the failed-breakdown setup, and it is the one setup in this playbook that works in red regimes, because it feeds on exactly the conditions red regimes produce.

The pattern

                  level (200 SMA, prior low, base bottom)
  ___/\___     ______________________________
           \  /                              \      /  <- entry: close back above level
            \/  <- break: 1 to 5 days below   \___/      with higher low in place
             \___/\___/                         ^
                                                stop: below the reclaim low

Conditions:

  1. A level that matters. The 200-day SMA, a multi-month low, the bottom of a base, or a round number that has been tested repeatedly. Obscure levels do not trap enough people.
  2. A clean break. One to five daily closes below the level. Volume on the break should be elevated; that is the stop-run.
  3. The reclaim. A daily close back above the level, on volume at least equal to the break's, with the reclaim day's low above the lowest low of the break.
  4. Context. The stock is a former or current leader (6-month RS top 30%). Broken laggards reclaim levels and then break them again.

Entry trigger

The first daily close back above the level. Do not anticipate; the difference between a failed breakdown and a successful one is only visible at the close. If the reclaim close comes with volume over 1.5x average, enter at the close; if volume is average, enter on the next day's confirmation, a trade above the reclaim day's high.

Stop

Below the lowest low of the breakdown, plus a 0.25 ATR buffer. This is one of the tighter stops in the playbook relative to the move it targets, because the breakdown low is the exact point where the thesis (that the breakdown failed) is proven wrong.

Targets

  • First target: the middle of the prior range, or the 20 EMA if price is well below it. Typically 1.5 to 2R.
  • Second target: the top of the prior range or the prior swing high. Often 3R or more, because reclaims start from a low point.

R:R table

Stock broke its 200 SMA at $42.00, traded down to $39.10 over three days on heavy volume, then closed back above $42.00 at $42.60 on 1.8x volume. ATR $1.30. Prior range top $50.

Element Price Distance In R
Entry (reclaim close) $42.60 — —
Stop (breakdown low − 0.25 ATR) $38.78 $3.82 1.0R
Target 1 (20 EMA area) $46.00 $3.40 0.9R
Target 2 (range top) $50.00 $7.40 1.9R

Target 2 falls just under 2R, so this specific reclaim is marginal. Two ways to fix it: wait for a lower-risk entry on the retest of $42 from above, which might cut the stop distance to $2.00 and lift target 2 to 3.7R; or pass. What you do not do is take the marginal version and hope.

With the retest entry at $42.30 and a stop at $40.30, a $200 budget buys 100 shares, a $4,230 position.

Key idea: A failed breakdown is a trapped crowd. Enter on the close back above the level, stop below the breakdown low, and target the other side of the range where the trapped sellers will finally give up.

What invalidates

  • A close back below the level after the reclaim. The reclaim failed. Exit on that close; the stop is a backstop, not the plan.
  • Reclaim on low volume. Nobody was trapped; it was a drift. Skip.
  • The break was orderly rather than a stop-run. Five days of slow, low-volume declines under the level is a trend, not a trap.
  • A second break of the same level within two weeks. Levels that fail twice tend to fail properly. Delete the name.
  • Stock is a long-term laggard. Bottom-half RS names reclaim and re-break constantly.

Where it shines

The failed-breakdown setup is most reliable at three moments:

  1. Index washouts. When the percentage of stocks above their 50 MA is under 20 and the index undercuts an obvious low then closes back above it, the leaders that reclaim first are the next uptrend's leaders.
  2. Post-earnings shakeouts. A leader that gaps down through support on earnings and then reclaims the level within three days has just absorbed every panicked seller.
  3. Range lows in a correction. In an amber regime, reclaims of range bottoms provide the best-defined stops in the market.

Beyond stocks

In crypto this is the "liquidity sweep": a run below an obvious low that reverses inside a day. The rule set is the same, and the reclaim close is even more important because intraday wicks below levels are routine. In forex, failed breaks of round numbers and prior weekly lows are the classic version; use the daily close. In index futures, failed breaks of the prior week's low are the equivalent and often coincide with the index washout described above.

Try it: Find the last time your index closed below its 200-day SMA and then closed back above it. Note how many days it stayed below and what breadth looked like. Then find three leaders that reclaimed a level in the same window and build the R:R table for each.

Recap

  • The setup requires a widely watched level, a clean break of 1 to 5 days on heavy volume, and a close back above it on at least equal volume.
  • Trigger: the reclaim close, or the next day's trade above its high if volume was average.
  • Stop: just under the breakdown low; target the middle and top of the prior range.
  • Exit on any close back below the level; do not wait for the stop.
  • It is the only setup allowed in red regimes and works best at index washouts and post-earnings shakeouts.

See it drawn

Original diagrams for the ideas on this page. Illustrative, not real market data.

A range beside a trendOne chart swinging between a flat floor and ceiling, another stepping upwards inside a pair of sloping lines.Range-boundresistancesupportprice bounces between two levelsTrendingthe trend channelhigher highs and higher lowsA range has two flat edges; a trend has two sloping ones.
Range versus trend. On the left price keeps bouncing between the same floor and ceiling, which is a range. On the right each high and each low is higher than the last, inside a pair of sloping lines called a channel.
Risk and reward on one tradeA price scale showing an entry with a stop two points below and a target six points above, so the reward band is three times the risk band.PRICETARGET 106.00ENTRY 100.00STOP 98.00REWARDRISK6.00 pointsthree times the risk2.00 pointsthe most you loserisk : reward = 1 : 3
Risk and reward on one trade. One trade on a price scale: the entry sits 2.00 points above the stop and 6.00 points below the target, so the shaded reward band is three times the risk band. The ratio compares what is lost if the stop is hit with what is gained if the target is reached.
Breakout and retestPrice stalls under one level, pushes above it, comes back to touch it from above, then continues higher.pricetimeold resistancenow support1price keeps stalling2breaks above3pulls back and retests it4and carries on
Breakout and retest. Price stalls under the same level several times, pushes above it, then drops back to touch it from above before carrying on. That touch is the retest, where the old ceiling is tried as a floor. A break that falls straight back under it is a false breakout.