The number is only honest if the benchmark is chosen before the trade. Picking the flattering comparison after the fact is how firms convince themselves execution is fine while paying away their edge.
Track it per strategy and per order type, in basis points, with a distribution rather than an average. slippage is fat-tailed: the mean is dominated by a handful of bad fills during fast moves.
Example: 240 entries over a month, average slippage of 1.8 ticks against a $12.50 tick — $5,400 on 240 single-contract trades. The median is 0.5 ticks; nine trades around news account for 62% of the total. The fix is not "trade better", it is "do not use market orders in the first minute after data".
Related: slippage, execution-quality, implementation-shortfall, average-fill-price