Skip to content
GetProfitable
Search

Setups 2 and 3: Failed breakout, and pullback to a level

Lesson 19 · about 10 min

Two more setups, built from the same parts. The failed breakout is what happens when the breakout in Lesson 2 does not hold; it trades in the opposite direction with a different trapped group. The pullback to a level is the basic trend-continuation trade, and it is the one most traders should learn first because the trend does most of the work.

Setup 2: Failed breakout

The sequence:

  1. A level exists (range top, swing high, prior day high).
  2. Price trades through it, by wick or by a brief close.
  3. Within one to three candles, price closes back on the original side of the level.
  4. Entry in the direction of the failure; stop beyond the extreme of the poke; target at the opposite side of the range or the next level.
Candle Open High Low Close Event
1 74.20 75.10 73.90 74.90 Range top zone 75.00-75.30
2 74.90 75.80 74.70 75.40 Close just above the zone; breakout buyers enter
3 75.40 75.90 74.30 74.50 Close back below 75.00: failed breakout
4 74.40 74.60 73.20 73.40 Follow-through down
                    |
                  +---+     |
  75.30 ----------|---|---+---+--------------------
  zone  //////////|///|///|###|////////////////////  <- range top
  75.00 ----------+---+---|###|--------------------
         |          |     |###|
       +---+              +---+
       |   |                |     |
       +---+                    +---+
         |                      |###|
                                +---+
                                  |
       1        2         3       4

Who is trapped: everyone who bought the breakout on candle 2 (75.00 to 75.80) and at the open of candle 3. They bought the highest prices on the chart and, one candle later, are all underwater. Their stops sit below the range top or below candle 2's low (74.70), and candle 3's close at 74.50 has already triggered many of them. The remaining ones sell any rally back to 75.00 to get out flat.

This is the setup with the largest and most painful trapped group per candle, because breakout buyers are by definition buying at the extreme. It is also why candle 3 is so often an outside bar or a bearish engulfing (Module 2): the reversal from above the level to below it covers the whole previous candle.

Entry, stop, target, with average range 1.00:

  • Entry: 74.30, a break of candle 3's low (confirmation the failure is continuing).
  • Stop: above the poke's high, 75.90, plus buffer 0.20: 76.10.
  • Target: the range bottom, say 71.80.
  • Risk = 76.10 − 74.30 = 1.80. Reward = 74.30 − 71.80 = 2.50. R:R = 2.50 ÷ 1.80 = 1.39.

A modest R:R because the poke was tall. A shorter poke (high 75.50) gives a stop at 75.70, risk 1.40, R:R 1.79. The size of the wick sets the stop, and the stop sets the R:R; there is no way around this.

Key idea: A failed breakout traps the traders who bought the extreme. The stop goes above that extreme, because if price accepts back above it the breakout was not a failure after all.

Where it fails: in a genuine trend. A "failed breakout" against a weekly uptrend is usually just a pullback that resumes. Run the multi-timeframe check; failed breakouts are strongest at range edges and at levels the context timeframe also sees as resistance.

Setup 3: Pullback to a level in a trend

The sequence:

  1. The context and trading timeframes agree on a trend.
  2. Price pulls back to a level: the most recent higher low, a flipped resistance, a prior day low in an intraday uptrend, or an anchored VWAP.
  3. A candle at the level shows the pullback ending (hammer, engulfing, or an inside bar followed by a break in the trend direction).
  4. Entry with the candle; stop beyond the pullback low; target at the most recent swing high or beyond it.

This is the Module 5, Lesson 1 worked example, so the numbers are already familiar: uptrend, level 61.80, hammer on day 5 with low 60.90 and high 62.30, average range 1.30.

  • Entry: 62.30, break of the hammer's high.
  • Stop: 60.90 minus buffer 0.26: 60.64.
  • Target 1: the prior swing high, 66.40.
  • Risk = 62.30 − 60.64 = 1.66. Reward = 66.40 − 62.30 = 4.10. R:R = 4.10 ÷ 1.66 = 2.47.

Who is trapped: the pullback sellers of days 2-5, and specifically those who sold below 61.80 on day 5. Who squeezes them: the trend buyers, who have defended every higher low so far. The trend is doing the work; the level and the candle just tell you where and when.

Why the pullback is the beginner's setup

  • The stop is close (just beyond the pullback low, which is a defined swing).
  • The target is defined (the last swing high) and usually further than the stop, so the R:R is naturally favourable.
  • The trend is a tailwind: even a mediocre entry tends to get bailed out by the larger structure.
  • The failure mode is clean: a close below the pullback low is a CHoCH, and the trade is wrong for a reason you can name.

Where it fails: deep pullbacks that break the higher low (a CHoCH), mature trends where the last swing high is close and the R:R is poor, and pullbacks with no candle, where you are buying a falling price at a line and hoping.

Comparing the three setups

Setup Trapped group Entry Stop Target
Breakout and retest Shorts from the level; breakout faders Break of retest candle high Beyond retest low + buffer Next level in trend direction
Failed breakout Breakout buyers at the extreme Break of failure candle low Beyond the poke high + buffer Opposite side of range / next level
Pullback to level Pullback sellers Break of reversal candle high Beyond pullback low + buffer Last swing high, then next level

All three have the same shape: a trapped group, a candle that shows them being squeezed, a stop where the story breaks, a target at the next place the opposition is expected. Learn the shape and the setups are three examples of it.

Try it: On one intraday chart, find one of each setup from the last two weeks. For each, write the trapped group in one sentence, then compute entry, stop, target and R:R using the buffer rule (20% of average range). Compare the three R:R figures. Which setup gave the best number, and was that because of the stop distance or the target distance?

Recap

  • Failed breakout: a poke through a level followed by a close back on the original side; trapped group is the breakout buyers; stop beyond the poke; strongest at range edges.
  • Pullback to a level: trend plus a level plus a reversal candle; trapped group is the pullback sellers; stop beyond the pullback low; target at the last swing high.
  • The pullback is the beginner's setup because the trend does most of the work and the failure (a CHoCH) is clean.
  • All three setups share one shape: trapped group, squeeze candle, stop where the story breaks, target at the next opposition.
  • The wick sets the stop, the stop sets the R:R; compute it before entering.

See it drawn

Original diagrams for the ideas on this page. Illustrative, not real market data.

Breakout and retestPrice stalls under one level, pushes above it, comes back to touch it from above, then continues higher.pricetimeold resistancenow support1price keeps stalling2breaks above3pulls back and retests it4and carries on
Breakout and retest. Price stalls under the same level several times, pushes above it, then drops back to touch it from above before carrying on. That touch is the retest, where the old ceiling is tried as a floor. A break that falls straight back under it is a false breakout.
The parts of a candlestickAn up candle and a down candle with the same high and low, labelled with open, high, low, close, the real body and the wicks.UP CANDLEclose above openHigh 41.00Close 40.30Open 38.20Low 37.40upper wickreal bodyopen to closelower wickDOWN CANDLEclose below openHigh 41.00Open 40.30Close 38.20Low 37.40Same high and low; only the open and close swap places.
The parts of a candlestick. One candle sums up a slice of time: the thick real body runs from the opening price to the closing price, and the thin wicks reach out to the highest and lowest prices traded. Colour tells you which way the body ran.
A range beside a trendOne chart swinging between a flat floor and ceiling, another stepping upwards inside a pair of sloping lines.Range-boundresistancesupportprice bounces between two levelsTrendingthe trend channelhigher highs and higher lowsA range has two flat edges; a trend has two sloping ones.
Range versus trend. On the left price keeps bouncing between the same floor and ceiling, which is a range. On the right each high and each low is higher than the last, inside a pair of sloping lines called a channel.