Skip to content
GetProfitable
Search

Slippage, chasing and the open

Lesson 21 · about 8 min

Slippage is the difference between the price you intended and the price you got. It is largest at the exact moment most day traders are most active, the first few minutes after 9:30, and it is the mechanism by which a good setup taken slightly late becomes a bad trade. This lesson measures it, shows when it matters, and gives you rules against the behaviour that causes most of it: chasing.

Where slippage comes from

Three sources, in order of size on the open:

  1. The spread. A market order buys at the ask. At 9:31 in a large cap the spread can be $0.05 instead of $0.01; in ES it is usually still one tick, in NQ often two.
  2. Book depth. A market order for more than the displayed size at the inside walks up the book. At 9:31 the book is thin because market makers pull quotes until price discovery settles.
  3. Latency. The price you saw is a few hundred milliseconds old. In a fast market, several ticks can trade in that time.

Measured on the open, a large-cap market order of 500 shares at 9:31 typically slips 2 to 5 cents; the same order at 10:15 slips under a cent. In ES, a market order at 9:30:30 slips one to two ticks; at 10:00, usually zero to one.

Time Large cap, 500 sh ES, 1 to 5 contracts NQ, 1 to 3 contracts
9:30 to 9:32 2 to 5 cents 1 to 2 ticks 2 to 4 ticks
9:32 to 9:40 1 to 2 cents 0 to 1 tick 1 to 2 ticks
9:40 to 10:30 under 1 cent 0 to 1 tick 0 to 1 tick
10:30 to 15:30 under 1 cent 0 0 to 1 tick
15:50 to 16:00 1 to 3 cents 0 to 1 tick 1 to 2 ticks

Slippage in R

As with cost, the number that matters is slippage divided by risk. A 4-cent slip on a $0.40 stop is 0.1R on the entry, and if the stop is also a market order in a fast tape, another 0.1R on the exit. A setup that expects +0.3R has just lost two-thirds of its edge to timing. The same setup with a $0.80 stop loses 0.05R per side.

This is why the ORB in Module 4 waits for the 5-minute range and enters on a stop order, and why gap-and-go is restricted to liquid names. The setups that trigger earliest are the ones where slippage does the most damage, and they need the widest stops in R terms to survive it.

Slippage on the stop is also why the stop's noise buffer exists. A stop order that triggers in a fast market becomes a market order and fills where the book allows. In a thin small cap the fill can be a full percent worse than the stop price; in ES it is rarely more than a tick. Product choice is slippage control.

Chasing

Chasing is entering after the trigger, at a worse price, because the move confirmed what you expected and you did not want to miss it. It feels like conviction. It is a systematic R:R downgrade:

  ORB planned vs chased

  planned:  entry 100.45, stop 99.95, target 101.20
            risk 0.50, reward 0.75  ->  1.5R

  chased:   entry 100.75, stop 99.95 (same structure), target 101.20
            risk 0.80, reward 0.45  ->  0.56R

  Same trade, same outcome distribution, 63% less reward per unit risk.

Three rules against it:

  1. The entry has a price, and the price has an expiry. For every trigger, the maximum acceptable entry is the trigger price plus a quarter of the stop distance. Beyond that the order is cancelled, not adjusted. For the ORB above, entries above 100.57 do not happen.
  2. A missed trade is a zero, not a loss. Write "missed, no chase" in the log and count it as a correct decision. The log will show you that most missed trades would have been chased into worse R:R than the ones you took.
  3. The retest is the second chance. A breakout that runs without you usually offers a pullback to the level within ten minutes. Set a limit order at the trigger price with the bracket attached and let the market decide whether you get in.

The open's two traps

Trap one: the first bar. The first 1-minute bar of the session has the worst slippage of the day and a direction that is a coin flip. Entering in it is paying maximum cost for zero edge. The only setup that permits it is gap-and-go in a liquid name, and even there, the entry is on the second bar's confirmation, not the first bar's move.

Trap two: the halted or gapped stop. In stocks, a volatility halt can freeze the tape for five minutes and reopen far beyond your stop. Your bracket stop becomes a market order at the reopen. This risk is why the small-cap group is excluded, and why size in any stock near a halt threshold (a 10% move in five minutes) should be small enough that a 5% adverse reopen is survivable. Index futures have price limits but no single-instrument halts of this kind; it is one more argument for them.

Practical slippage control

  • Enter breakouts with stop orders at the trigger, not market orders after it.
  • Enter pullbacks and fades with limits; if it does not fill, it does not fill.
  • Size so that the worst realistic slip on the stop (a few ticks in futures, a few cents in a large cap) is under 0.1R.
  • Do not trade the first minute.
  • Record intended price and filled price on every trade. Average slippage in R is a number you should know for your product.

Key idea: Slippage is paid twice, on the way in and on the stop, and it is largest exactly when the fastest setups trigger. The controls are order type, product choice, size and the refusal to chase past a fixed price.

Try it: For your next 20 trades, record intended and actual fill on both entry and exit. Compute average slippage per side in your product's units, then in R. If it is above 0.05R per side, the next step is one of: wider stop in R (smaller size), later entries, or a more liquid product.

Recap

  • Slippage comes from spread, book depth and latency; all three peak in the first two minutes and again in the last ten.
  • Measure it in R: a 4-cent slip on a $0.40 stop is 0.1R per side.
  • Chasing converts a 1.5R trade into a 0.56R trade with the same outcome distribution; cap entries at trigger plus a quarter of the stop.
  • Use stop orders for breakouts, limits for pullbacks; never market orders in the first minute.
  • Halts in stocks can reopen far beyond a stop; keep size small near halt thresholds or use futures.

See it drawn

Original diagrams for the ideas on this page. Illustrative, not real market data.

Slippage on a market orderA buy order clears four price levels, so the average price paid is worse than the price first quoted.Buy 1,000 shares at marketpricesell orders resting (bar length = size)20.04300 shares20.03200 shares20.01200 shares20.00300 sharesnothing resting at 20.02order sweeps up the bookaverage fill 20.02SLIPPAGE0.02 a share$20.00 in totalintended 20.00Each level fills at its own price; the average is what you really paid.
Slippage on a market order. You click at 20.00, but only 300 shares are resting there, so the rest of the order fills at 20.01, 20.03 and 20.04. The average price paid is 20.02, and that two-cent gap is slippage.
Market, limit and stop ordersA price track crossing a resting limit order below the market and a stop order above it.10410210098PriceTime (the market moves left to right)priceSTOP BUY at 103.00waits above the market; becomes a market order when touchedtriggers hereMARKET ORDERfills at once at 100.60filled hereLIMIT BUY at 98.50rests below; fills only at 98.50 or better
Market, limit and stop orders. A market order buys straight away at whatever price is there. A limit order waits below until the price comes to it, and a stop order sits above and turns into a market order the moment price touches it.
Bid-ask spread in an order bookSell orders stacked above buy orders with a gap between the best of each.SELLERS (asks)50.0690050.051,40050.0460050.011,10050.002,30049.99800spread = 0.03BUYERS (bids)
The bid-ask spread. Buy orders sit below, sell orders above, and the gap between the best bid (50.01) and best ask (50.04) is the spread you pay to cross. Bar length shows the size resting at each price.